Compare candidates

Compare Taproot Survey responses from up to four candidates side-by-side


Select candidates to compare


Andrew Knack

Andrew Knack

Candidate for mayor



Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your view of the most important function of a councillor?

Knack

Community representative.

Candidate comments: “Building a Stronger Edmonton is about putting the needs of Edmontonians first. We need to make sure that our city works for everyone. That means better services, safer communities, and economic growth that benefits everybody.”
Mixed

Which would you prioritize regarding property taxes?

Knack

Increase taxes only to keep up with inflation and population growth.

Candidate comments: “Increasing taxes that keeps up with inflation and population growth will allow us to improve the quality of life of Edmontonians.”


Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your view on 15-minute districts?

Knack

Let the market provide more mixed-use development and local services.

Candidate comments: “I support incentivizing more local services so people have the choice to live more locally.”
Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your approach to development outside Anthony Henday Drive?

Knack

Set a firm growth boundary.

Candidate comments: “I'm comfortable with the growth boundaries as set in the City Plan.”
Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to how you would guide infill development?

Knack

Slow the pace with stronger regulations.

Candidate comments: “I support a reduction back to 6 units mid-block, mature tree preservation, support the Heritage Place Strategy to ensure the character of our neighbourhoods is preserved. I also support the further development of the Priority Growth Areas to offset the mid-block changes.”


Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to how you would incorporate climate change into decision-making?

Knack

The climate crisis must be a consideration in every single decision.

Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to how you would approach parking in commercial areas?

Knack

Reduce parking and reallocate land to other uses.

Candidate comments: “The current epark/Hotspot system needs to be improved as there are too many people who do not feel the system is working for them. Reallocation of land to other uses should be focused on housing and mixed-use development.”
Mixed

Which would you prioritize for downtown revitalization funds?

Knack

Grow the residential population.



Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your position on public funding for the arts?

Knack

Essential to quality of life and in need of stable funding.

Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your approach to economic development?

Knack

Invest in entrepreneurship and local businesses.

Candidate comments: “In my platform, I have a detailed economic policy which includes attracting new businesses, investing in entrepreneurship and local business, and removing barriers to business growth. All of these are critical to our city's economic development.”
Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your approach to development in the river valley?

Knack

Protect it as a continuous natural area.

Candidate comments: “While my voting record has prioritized protecting the River Valley as a continuous natural area, I am willing to consider very thoughtful development of public amenities and in select locations (ex: River Crossing) dependent on thorough engagement with Indigenous Peoples.”


Mixed

Which would you prioritize regarding aging recreation amenities?

Knack

Decommission aging facilities and build replacements.

Candidate comments: “Social infrastructure is critical to the quality of life for all Edmontonians. These amenities should be available across all communities in Edmonton.”
Mixed

Which action would you be most likely to advocate for on homelessness?

Knack

Build and operate more permanent supportive housing.

Mixed

Which action would you be most likely to advance to alleviate the housing crisis?

Knack

Build housing, even without provincial or federal partners.

Candidate comments: “I will always pursue partnership with other orders of government, private sector, and non-profit organizations to increase the supply of affordable housing in Edmonton. People are not political footballs especially when there are cost-effective, proven, and evidence-based solutions that save money and lives.”


Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your view on political parties at the municipal level?

Knack

Members of council should be free from party affiliation.

Mixed

If the City of Edmonton faces public pressure to fund services under provincial jurisdiction, which would you prioritize?

Knack

Fund the services to ensure quality of life.

Candidate comments: “We need to invite all levels of government to the table but I will no longer use jurisdiction as an excuse when lives are at stake.”


Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your view on how major projects have been delivered?

Knack

Performance is unsatisfactory because project management and execution are poor.

Candidate comments: “The vast majority of City projects are finished on budget and on schedule but the cumulative impact of projects has made life challenging for Edmontonians and local businesses. I have championed new ways to complete construction that has shorten construction timelines and can now be used across the city.”
Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your approach to building new capital projects?

Knack

Build even if it means taking on more debt.

Candidate comments: “We need to use restraint in borrowing for large projects but we also need to ensure that all communities in Edmonton have access to the basic amenities they need. Fire halls, recreation centers, libraries, police stations, etc. are not frivolous.”
Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your position on roadway expansion?

Knack

Expansion is important to reduce traffic congestion and accommodate growth.

Candidate comments: “Induced demand is real. There is also a need to address certain pinch points because they impact our transit service and have an impact on commute times in this city. We must continue to invest in transit as part of any transportation network expansion.”


Mixed

Which of the following comes closest to your approach to strengthening council accountability?

Knack

Implement a lobbyist registry.

Candidate comments: “A lobbyist registry should be the bare minimum.”
Mixed

Which action would you be most likely to advocate for to improve community safety?

Knack

Invest in addressing root causes to reduce disorder.

Candidate comments: “My community safety plan requires all three options to be advanced.”
Mixed

Which action would you be most likely to advocate for to improve street safety?

Knack

Increase enforcement of bylaws.

Candidate comments: “As the person who championed the creation of Vision Zero Street Labs, I am committed to continued investment in traffic-calming measures.”


Mixed

Which action would you be most likely to advocate for on bike lanes?

Knack

Build only what has already been planned.

Candidate comments: “To be clear, the initial investment is not all that has been planned and there is a detailed Bike Plan that shows where we should be building infrastructure and I believe it's important to continue that work.”
Mixed

Which would you prioritize for snow clearing?

Knack

Spend more to improve clearing of roads.

Candidate comments: “I support spending more to improve the clearing of roads and the clearing of sidewalks/pathways, particularly around seniors residences and centres.”
Mixed

Which would you prioritize for high-capacity transit?

Knack

Prioritize bus rapid transit (BRT).

Candidate comments: “Based on our upcoming 4-year capital budget, BRT is the most realistic high-capacity transit option that we will be able to fund. Although, I will advocate to the other orders of government to continue the expansion of existing LRT routes to other parts of the city (ex: Castle Downs).”